Blog

In storytelling, conflict is king. While it’s natural to focus on what your characters want to happen, sometimes the most compelling plots come from exploring what happens when everything goes wrong. Reverse brainstorming is a creative technique that flips conventional problem-solving on its head, encouraging you to imagine worst-case scenarios and use them to fuel your narrative.

Here’s how embracing chaos can lead to stronger, more dynamic stories.

1. Start with the Goal

Begin by identifying what your characters are trying to achieve.

• Does your protagonist want to save a loved one?
• Are they trying to land a dream job?
• Are they fighting to keep their town safe from a looming threat?

Once you have the goal in mind, think about all the ways things could go off course.

2. Ask, “What’s the Worst That Could Happen?”

Let your imagination run wild and pile on the obstacles.

• The loved one doesn’t just disappear—they’re taken by someone the protagonist trusted.
• The dream job interview doesn’t just flop—the protagonist accidentally insults the CEO in front of the entire team.
• The town isn’t just under threat—it’s betrayed from within by its leader.

This exercise forces you to push your story into uncharted territory, uncovering new depths of conflict and tension.

3. Add Layers of Complications

Once you’ve brainstormed initial setbacks, layer additional challenges to create a snowball effect.

• The protagonist loses their way while pursuing the antagonist. Then, their mode of transportation breaks down. Then, they’re stranded in enemy territory.
• The romantic lead doesn’t just misinterpret a gesture—they overhear a conversation that makes them question the protagonist’s intentions.

Each complication should make the protagonist’s situation worse, forcing them to adapt and grow.

4. Create Emotional Stakes

It’s not enough for things to go wrong physically—emotional stakes make setbacks truly resonate.

• How does failure impact your character’s self-esteem or relationships?
• Does the betrayal of a close friend leave them doubting their instincts?
• Does losing a battle make them question their purpose?

Emotional fallout deepens the conflict and keeps readers invested.

5. Explore the Domino Effect

Reverse brainstorming often reveals how one failure can lead to a cascade of problems.

• A protagonist fails to defuse a bomb. This triggers an explosion that exposes their team’s location, leading to an ambush.
• A character forgets an important event, damaging a relationship. This distraction causes them to make a critical error at work, leading to career consequences.

By thinking through the domino effect, you can create a tightly woven plot where every action has meaningful consequences.

6. Use Worst-Case Scenarios to Define Character Growth

The way characters respond to failure reveals their resilience, creativity, and determination.

• Do they fall apart or rise to the challenge?
• Do they blame others, or take responsibility?
• How do they find hope or strength in the midst of chaos?

Your characters’ reactions to these challenges will shape their arcs and make their eventual triumphs even more satisfying.

7. Play with Genre Tropes

Reverse brainstorming can also help you subvert genre expectations.

• In a mystery, what if the detective’s first major clue is a trap laid by the antagonist?
• In a romance, what if the meet-cute turns into a public humiliation?
• In a fantasy quest, what if the hero’s magical weapon turns out to be cursed?

By twisting tropes, you can surprise your audience and keep your story fresh.

8. Embrace Uncertainty

Sometimes, the best stories come from moments where the protagonist (and the audience) doesn’t know how they’ll recover.

• Let your characters hit rock bottom.
• Allow them to make mistakes that worsen the situation.
• Force them to face dilemmas with no easy answers.

Uncertainty creates tension and keeps readers turning the page.

9. Balance Chaos with Hope

While reverse brainstorming thrives on imagining disasters, balance is key. Readers need glimmers of hope to stay engaged.

• Introduce small victories or moments of connection amidst the chaos.
• Show your character learning from their failures and building the tools to overcome obstacles.

This balance ensures that the story remains gripping without becoming overwhelming.

10. Use Failure to Reinforce the Theme

When everything goes wrong, it’s an opportunity to reinforce your story’s central message.

• A story about perseverance might show a character refusing to give up despite repeated failures.
• A story about redemption could explore how a character learns from their mistakes to make amends.
• A story about trust could test relationships under extreme pressure, highlighting the value of forgiveness and loyalty.

Linking setbacks to your theme ensures that your story feels cohesive and meaningful.